Aim: The aim of this prospective clinical trial was to analyse the ventral fusion rate following circumferential fusion for degenerative spine disease using a radiolucent carbon fibre cage (Brantigan, Fa. DePuy-Acromed) loaded with either autogeneous bone graft (iliac crest) or with the tricalcium phosphate Cerasorb with PRP (Curasan AG, Kleinostheim, Deutschland).
Methods: In 26 patients (15 female, 11 male, average age: 57.7 years) a circumferential fusion of the lumbar spine was performed (titanium posterior instrumentation and Brantigan, Fa. DePuy-Acromed). Autogeneous bone graft (iliac crest) and Cerasorb-PRP as cage filling substance were randomly assigned to each level in all patients. Anterior fusion was evaluated in a total number of 69 Brantigan cages by radiographs after 3, 6, 9 and 12 months and by CT 1 year after surgery.
Results: The evaluation of radiographs resulted in a fusion rate 49 %. This was significantly different from the fusion rate accessed by CT scanning (28 %). None of the Brantigan cages (n = 33) filled with Cerasorb with PRP showed an anterior fusion in the CT while fusion was proven in 19 of 36 (49 %) Brantigan cages loaded with cancellous bone from the iliac crest.
Conclusion: The use a of cancellous bone from the iliac crest as filling substance for Brantigan cages in circumferential fusion of the lumbar spine leads to a significantly higher anterior fusion rate than Cerasorb with PRP.