We randomized 31 children with a 1st afebrile unprovoked seizure to receive carbamazepine (CBZ) or no medication for 1 year or until the time of a 2nd seizure. All seizures had a focal onset or were generalized tonic-clonic. Overall, 2/14 randomized to CBZ and 9/17 with no medication had a recurrent afebrile seizure. Compliance with CBZ was excellent in 12/14, but noncompliance may have contributed to 1 of the recurrences with CBZ. Four discontinued CBZ because of side effects. Two additional children taking CBZ had a febrile seizure. Thus, only 6/14 taking CBZ had a year completely seizure-free with no unacceptable medication side effects. Of those taking no medication, 2 had a febrile recurrence, and 7/17 had a year completely-seizure free. Side effects and febrile recurrences may limit the value of CBZ for some children, although CBZ appears to reduce significantly recurrences after a 1st afebrile seizure.