DNA profiles generated by different STR kits may show different alleles for identical amplified loci. This well-known phenomenon affects the smooth transition of data generated by new STR kits to a database or casework laboratory or cross-laboratory comparison of STR profiles. As in other DNA databases throughout the world, it has become clear that the number of the analyzed loci should be expanded for a variety of reasons, such as partial profiles resulting from low copy-number DNA template or degraded samples, working with mixtures or when prevalence of familial inbreeding. In the course of introducing a new STR kit, VeriFiler™ Express (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA), we compared genotyping data of 1568 samples amplified by the VeriFiler™ Express with the data generated on the same samples by the Powerplex™ ESI FAST (Promega, Madison WI, USA) kit. Discordance was noted in 20 samples (1.27%), 14 (0.89%) of them showing allele dropout mismatch and six (0.38%) showing an additional fixed-size third allele. These rates are well above the reported rates of 0.4% for this kit. Since correct genotyping and accurate consistent allele assignment is of paramount importance, it seems timely to recommend for DNA laboratories and genetic-match search systems to take these possible inconsistencies into account.
Keywords: DNA database; Powerplex ESI FAST kit; VeriFiler Express kit; allele dropout; discordance.
© 2020 American Academy of Forensic Sciences.