The sesquiterpene-tropolones belong to a distinctive structural class of meroterpene natural products with impressive biological activities, including anticancer, antifungal, antimalarial, and antibacterial. In this article, we describe a concise, modular, and cycloaddition-based approach to a series of sesquiterpene mono- and bistropolones, including (-)-epolone B, (+)-isoepolone B, (±)-dehydroxypycnidione, and (-)-10-epi-pycnidione. Alongside the development of a general strategy to access this unique family of metabolites were computational modeling studies that justified the diastereoselectivity observed during key cycloadditions. Ultimately, these studies prompted stereochemical reassignments of the pycnidione subclass and shed additional light on the biosynthesis of these remarkable natural products.