The discovery of new immune-modulating biomaterials is of significant value to immuno-engineering and therapy development. Here, we discovered that single-tailed heterocyclic carboxamide lipids preferentially modulated macrophages - but not dendritic cells - by interfering with sphingosine-1-phosphate-related pathways, consequently increasing interferon alpha expression. We further performed extensive downstream correlation analysis and determined key factors in physicochemical properties likely to modulate pro-inflammatory and anti-inflammatory immune responses. These properties will be useful for the rational design of the next generation of cell type-specific immune-modulating lipids.